Google Tag vs. Google Tag Manager: Which One Should I Use?

Two popular tools from Google, Google Tag (gtag.js) and Google Tag Manager (GTM), serve this purpose but differ significantly in functionality and use cases.

Let’s explore their differences, features, and when to use each.

What is Google Tag (gtag.js)?

Google Tag (gtag.js) is a standalone JavaScript library that allows you to send data directly to Google services such as Google Analytics (GA4) or Google Ads. It’s a lightweight solution, best suited for basic setups where you only need to track a few Google-specific events.

• Direct Tracking: gtag.js sends data directly to services like Analytics and Ads.
• Customization: Events and parameters are configured manually in the code.
• Best for Simplicity: Ideal for small websites with straightforward tracking needs.

What is Google Tag Manager (GTM)?

Google Tag Manager (GTM) is a powerful tag management system that enables you to manage and deploy multiple tracking codes, or tags, from a single platform without modifying your website’s source code.

• Centralized Management: Manage all tags in one place, including third-party tools like Facebook Pixel and LinkedIn Insights.
• Advanced Features: Includes triggers, variables, and debugging tools to create sophisticated tracking setups.
• User-Friendly: Marketers can add or update tags through a web interface without relying on developers.

Key Differences Between Google Tag and GTM

‍Ease of Use:

‍gtag.js requires manual coding and is great for simple setups, while GTM offers a user-friendly interface for managing tags without directly modifying the code.

Example: A small business might use gtag.js to track basic page views and conversions, but a marketing team managing multiple ad campaigns would benefit from GTM’s intuitive dashboard.

‍Scalability:

‍gtag.js works best for Google services like Analytics or Ads, whereas GTM supports both Google and third-party tools like Facebook Pixel or LinkedIn Insight.

Example: An e-commerce site using multiple advertising platforms would find GTM invaluable for consolidating all tracking tags in one place.

‍Debugging:

GTM includes a built-in Preview and Debug mode, making it easier to test and troubleshoot tags before they go live. gtag.js lacks this feature, requiring manual validation.

Example: A developer testing event tracking for form submissions can use GTM’s debug tools to ensure accuracy without disrupting live data.

Which Tool Should You Use?

The choice depends on your business needs:

Use Google Tag (gtag.js) if:

• You have a small-scale website with straightforward tracking.
• Your tracking needs are limited to Google services like Analytics or Ads.
• You prefer manual control over your tracking setup.
  ‍

Use Google Tag Manager (GTM) if:

• Your website involves multiple tools and services.
• You want to make updates without modifying your website’s code.
• Your tracking needs are complex, such as firing tags on specific user interactions.

Can You Use Both?

While you can use both tools together, it’s typically unnecessary. GTM can handle all tracking configurations for Google services, eliminating the need for gtag.js. On the other hand, if you’re using gtag.js, GTM isn’t required unless you expand your setup to include third-party tools or advanced features.

Ultimately, Google Tag is great for simplicity and direct control, while GTM shines in scenarios requiring scalability and flexibility. By understanding the strengths of each, you can choose the best solution to meet your analytics and marketing goals.

If you’re still unsure which tool is right for you, or if you need help setting up tracking, don’t hesitate to reach out. Our team of experts is here to guide you through the process and ensure your tracking is optimized for success.